These issues are MUCH more common than we realize.... and believe it or not these same issues are in other cultures around the world..... My first experience with a male id butch taught me that they are (speaking generally here folks) wired up in their heads as all male all the time, so to speak. They use "command" language as their primary communication style, and in many relationships i have known over the years, the most frustrating thing for most Butches is that they do not understand or "get" the traditional (united states) feminine style of communication....
Common mistakes are telling the butch (sometimes doesn't matter if male id or not), "figure it out" "I'm not gonna explain it to you, you should know what you did wrong".
All this does is increase the frustration level of the butch and continues to anger the femme because she thinks hye is playing stupid on purpose to piss her off..... nothing could be more wrong.... Clear communication can make or break a relationship into little pieces..... it's sad really, the information is out there, you just have to go to the library or google it online.... My take on this is that because when a butch has a female body presentation, it is easy to assume that the female bodied person is also wired to communicate like a feminine woman..... but that's not what is happening, my simple suggestion is to speak to a butch like you would your brother or dad and see if anything changes.....
I could talk all night about communication studies and what i have learned over many years of study.... of course it doesn't mean I'm a perfect communicator, because I have offended many people many times without meaning to, because i had a clueless moment and spoke out of turn, or something fell outta my mouth like a gumball machine...... I am continually embarrassed by my stupidity and lack of decorum at times...... and then there are other moments when i make perfect sense and say the right things at all the right times...... guess after that fire raged through my head things got a little toasted??? Well, that's the only thread i have to hang onto at this time.... Sorry, hope that made sense?
The term "2 x 4 butch" is a rude illustration of my point.... the idea that he has to be hit with a 2x4 to "get it", whatever "IT" is...... he is not clueless or playing stupid or trying to piss you off, or get away with something. He REALLY does not know what the hell you are talking about, because the feminine style is "persuasion" or something like that, i would have to look it up again to give you the correct terminology.... so unless you were raised to use or your brain was wired to "use" the feminine style the "command" language style person will never understand the "rules of engagement", in other words, what the heck is going on with all the talk talk talk and no information to hold onto.
Perhaps you know someone or heard someone say to their partner, "just spit it out, what the heck do you want from me? What do you want me to do?" That person is looking for instructions, a "command" request..... they can't decipher what they don't understand.... it's like asking someone to tell you what time it is, and in response to your request for the time, they give you an hour long monologue about why Suzie Q left her bf and what she should have done, and why it is never gonna fly with the way she dresses or styles her poodles before the dog show...... see how the two styles clash and make communication impossible???
Okay, now that i've done another marathon post, i will go for now and check back later if you have any questions or concerns, hope this helped a little bit.....
Remember the tv sitcom "Friends" and the one with Jerry Seinfeld? They are excellent at presenting all the strange nuances of human communication and meltdown of communication...... take a second look at those shows, you will "see" what i "mean"
Bookmarks